Tuesday, March 11, 2014

Perspectives of the City.

 It took a few days on the streets to fall completely out of love with San Francisco. The City had been a playground for late nights dancing, long days of walking to “see the sights,” and places to spend money for a piece of luxury. Now I was faced with the dichotomies of the beautiful, shiny buildings and the shit that actually paves the streets.

Like many, I bought into the fantasy of the heart of San Francisco. I imagine the City as this slinky woman in a sparkly dress that speaks in a husky voice: “Come to me and I will hold you; I will kiss your wounds and made it all well.” Lady Francisca whispers to the lonely outsiders and offers a mild climate with a comforting bosom on which the hurting can rest their heads. This lady points to the sparkling blue Bay, the rust colored arches of the Golden Gate, and the mysterious fog as the environment where souls can be restored. But here's the thing: Lady Francisca is bullshit.

Lady Francisca has deep, sharp claws that will sink into your pocketbooks and flesh until you are dried up. Lady Francisca offers you a few hits to kick back and relax until your brain is obsessed with the next fix and the fix is no longer a kind gesture but a demanding fist. This mystical place of hippie love, space for all, and progressive politics pays close attention to the color of your skin: if your skin is not white, it does not matter if you were born here or work hard or have dreams.

I walked the streets and peered into the corners of this City of “Free Love” and found how many prices there are to pay to reside here. I saw the distrust in the eyes of faces that were hardened by years of judgement and being pushed out of their homes by the Bay. I saw the “affordable” high-rise lofts in the Filmore that replaced beloved neighborhoods of many African-Americans. I heard about the many years that Chinese immigrants and Chinese-Americans were kept inside the walls of Chinatown, not allowed to become a part of the community of San Francisco. I felt the desperation leaking out of people's voices as they whispered, then spoke, then yelled to be heard and seen from their spot on the streetcorner.

I lowered my eyes in shame as I waited in line to get food, use a restroom, or be able to sit down somewhere. There is nothing I could do to make myself not a young woman with shiny teeth and innocent eyes that glaringly told people that I did not know or understand the streets. My eyes deadened with exhaustion from sleeping on church floors and pews, walking for miles, and holding in pee, but that exhaustion didn't change that after 3 weeks of being immersed in the streets of San Francisco, I got to go home. As I walked the streets littered with trash, I knew that there were a few coins and bills in my bag that could pay my way into any coffeeshop or bar. What a luxury, to know that if worse came to worst, there were so many safety nets lined up for me to fall into. How terrifying to see that those nets can easily be broken apart into useless pieces of fabric.

The first days walking in San Francisco as a “cultural immerser” I felt myself on edge. My back was tightened, waiting for the sting of something or someone. The only person that was attacking me at that moment was myself; the fear held all of my ability to connect with others. I immediately felt changes as I boldly strolled down a darkened street as a night minister: I wanted to be seen and I wanted for people to talk to me. Every pair of eyes that I made eye contact with was someone that I could acknowledge, give a nod to, or maybe have a conversation with. I met the people that I would call the real Lady Franciscas: the night ministers who embrace those on the street who are hungry for comfort and a listening ear.

As I settled into being a person who walked the streets of San Francisco for hours each day, my eyes were opened in new ways. The people on the streets, whether they were hurriedly walking to an appointment, full-on running to catch the BART or bus, or sitting on a stoop while calling out for money, these people did not seem like strangers to me. I saw the fear in the eyes of young women walking down a dark street, I saw the seemingly powerful confidence of a suit-clad person walking with a cell phone. I watched many people pass by and ignore people that were sitting or standing on the sidewalk, asking for change. I have been that person that walked right by a person hoping for interaction; I have been an active part of this system of overlooking the real humanness of people in this city that we say we love so much. Rather than being a part of the system, I stepped back and saw all of these people as opportunities to learn more.

I walked past a man sitting on the street who was yelling out for someone to hear him: “ANYONE? DO YOU HAVE CHANGE?” His face was twisted in anguish as he called out to the people that quickly passed by who avoided his eyes. As more people encountered him and did not acknowledge his presence, his voice rose and fell in desperation. I looked over towards him and our eyes locked. 

The man's face changed so instantaneously that I was in shock. His desperation and anger melted away into a smile that creased the skin around his eyes. He gave me a thumbs up as I asked him how his night was going; I told him I hoped he could find some warmth that night. He waved goodbye with that broad smile and said, “Thank you, bless you and enjoy your night!” I was astounded by the sudden happiness that leapt off of him as I took a few seconds to glance over at him. It seemed like there was a hunger that was running deeper than the need for a bite to eat or a warm, safe place to sit: he was deeply yearning for someone to see him as a person. This man gave me hope that night in the city that had been exposed to me as bleak, greedy, and cold.

The shiny lights of Lady Francisca still don't entice me the same that they once did. Yet I learned how to love San Francisco again from a man with a toothless smile who sat down with me at a senior citizen luncheon. This quiet guy talked me through his daily routine of begging for coffee each morning and then walking around the neighborhoods of San Francisco. He spoke of his favorite spots to view the rolling hills of San Francisco and the best benches to rest on for an hour or so. He described the Presidio's green trees with a fondness and familiarity; he advised about the best times to see the sun shine just right on the Golden Gate Bridge. After describing all of these beauties in the city, he said, “You know, every single place in this city holds so many perspectives; it just depends where and how you are looking at it.”

I can look at San Francisco from the eyes of a guarded woman walking alone in a darkened street; I can see this city from the eyes of a business person hurrying about their day. But I choose to see this Foggy City by the Bay from that man's gentle and caring eyes: I see the fog silently rolling in through the buildings or the sun shining on the pavement that is worn from walking. I see this City with tired feet and with a heart that is turned towards hope.

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Day Sixteen - January 21st - Food Bank and Love Banquet - "Where do I go from here?"

   "Where do I go from here?"

 Only three full days left.  Despite my occasional grumblings, it has been a really good experience.  As I look toward the end, I wonder not just what I have learned but how much it will stick with me once I am again living in relative luxury. Relative to the way I am living now, anyway.

     I have begun to learn a little of what it means to be homeless.  Some of the issues which I never would have realized have come to light through this process.  It's interesting because this final week is focused on serving, which I have done many, many times before, only now it is radically different.

     No matter how hard I try to justify it, every time I served before, somewhere in the back of my mind, I had an us vs. them attitude. Along the way I had some inaccurate opinions of the causes of homelessness and the ability of the homeless to get out of cycles of poverty.  I have come to understand that just because someone may have a roof over their head does not mean that they are settled or any less "homeless".

     Most of all, I have learned to see others as equals. No, more than that, that others, no matter their circumstance, are all writers of my life story and I of theirs.  The pages and chapters they contribute are just as valuable as any other.  Everyone has a story to share.  A good story, one worth listening to, no matter what. Those stories weave along with mine to create this wonderful human narrative.  All people have great value.  When did I forget that?

     When was it that I would have been afraid to clear the dishes and silverware that HIV positive people had just used for fear of catching something?  I did that just a few minutes ago and am somewhat ashamed I remembered a time when I might have thought that way.

     Part of the learning process this experience has given me is to realize that I am a little ashamed of the person I was before. Certainly ashamed of the person I was five, ten, and twenty years ago but, to be honest, ashamed of the person I was just a month ago.

     I still have room to grow and I will probably be ashamed of the person I am now in the near future. At least I hope so.

     I'm not totally sure who I am now. This experience has changed me, is changing me in a positive way.  I view people in a different light now, for sure.  I just hope this new way of looking at the world, this new way of looking at people, doesn't wear off!  That would be a shame.

     So I guess I need to figure out ways to hear the stories of others as I progress into ministry.  Maybe I'll eat at a food kitchen once a week.  Maybe when I do that I will wear a collar.  Maybe not. I'll try to seek out ways to hear the stories of others throughout my ministry.  I don't want to lose this.

Monday, January 20, 2014

Day Fifteen - January 20th - Day one of week three - "Rules"

Rules -

     I'm not sure how I feel about rules.  I'm probably somewhere in the middle between two extremes.  One end of the spectrum is "rules are meant to be broken" and the other end is defined by an almost compulsive need to follow every rule, no matter what, to the point of paralysis.

     I said in my journal for January 16th that "sometimes the logical decision is the wrong one" and I think this holds true here. Sometimes following the rules makes sense, to keep people safe, to keep things organized, etcetera. Sometimes following the rule is wrong.  Maybe it's based on a flawed notion.

     On this, Martin Luther King, Jr. day, we remember when following some of the rules was finally seen as wrong.  It was the rule that "whites sat in the front of the bus", but not to Rosa Parks.  It was the rule that "African Americans were not allowed to drink from white water fountains" or to "sit at the lunch counter at Woolworths", but not to those who sat there silently in protest anyway.

     I'm sure that there are rules in our society today that are present for the sole purpose of discrimination, but I only know of a few.  (Voter identification laws, anyone?) And each of them has a great "cover story" to make it not seem as if it is simply discrimination.  For instance, it is illegal to sit or lay down on sidewalks in San Francisco.  This clearly targets the homeless, but I'm sure it is covered up by some other rationale.

     My point is this. I'm sure there are rules in place that I haven't considered which discriminate unjustly against specific groups of people, which have a logical "cover story". I just don't know what they are because I am conditioned to accept and follow the rules in place, and assume that they are fair and just without questioning them.

Day One - January 6th - The Tenderloin.

I realized that I was posting every other journal entry anyway, so I may as well post my first one, which I had skipped. With each of the posts, we are trying to answer three questions.  What holds us separate?  What keeps me separate?  As I walk the streets, what still connects me?

Day One Journal

     I ate a free lunch today. I felt bad, like I was taking a meal from someone, at first.  I ate an orange, small, stringy, slightly past its prime, but still good and sweet. Ten minutes later I realized some of that orange got stuck between my teeth. I needed floss.  Why didn't I bring floss with me? Wow.  How privileged I am! I will let this piece of orange remind me today of my privilege.

     Another privilege, the privilege of loitering.  I remembered a time I was without housing for about a week.  Not homeless.  I had a career, I stayed in a hotel at night that week, but in the hours between work and hotel check in...where could I go? I went to a park or a parking lot in my car and...read or loitered.  It was uncomfortable and I worried I was going to be told to leave.  What if my life was loitering?  My whole life? How would I fill the time? Would I try to look busy like other people, bustling on their way to work or other places?

     If I was truly loitering...I wouldn't be able to use the restroom, unless I was a customer. What would I do then? Would I buy something inexpensive for the right to pee? Shouldn't everyone have the right to pee for free?

     And if I needed to contact someone, my friend, my parole officer, my mother, how would I charge my phone?  At the library, lots of people were charging their phones and checking in with people.

     I am so blessed and so privileged, to have my little, hole-in-the-wall, cave of an apartment, where I can privately pee, charge my phone and floss my teeth.  Where I can loiter to my hearts content and nobody will have a problem with it.

     I just remembered I have flossers in my pocket.  I'm going to get that orange out.

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Day Eleven - January 16th - "A different path"

     I took a different path and this time it was a dumb idea. I walked to St. Marks hurriedly because I was late and thought I could make it a little quicker by trying another route. I marched quickly straight up California street for three blocks. When I saw "up", I mean UP.  We had always gone another way when we went there. When I got to where I had to turn left, I was worn out from the climb. When I turned, the street ran downhill for several blocks. Not only that, but I realized I had climbed one block further than I needed to. I'm not going that way again.

     I've been thinking a lot about the choices I have made throughout my life, the paths I have taken. This experience has forced me to consider the ramifications of even some of the minor choices I have made.

     It should come as no surprise that my favorite poem is a favorite of many, Robert Frost's "The Road Not Taken". And on a side note, my favorite author Jorge Luis Borges had as one of his most famous stories, "The Garden of Forking Paths".

     Why do we make the choices we make? Why do we choose one path over another beyond the obvious points that one path benefits me more? What I mean is, if all things are equal, why do I choose one path over another, and how have those choices been led by the Holy Spirit?

     Most people who have an authentic call to be a pastor have noted a pull toward a path they might never have chosen, a path that doesn't make logical sense in some ways.  By "authentic" I am not judging, but noting that there are people who make the choice to go to seminary a more intellectual one, rather than an unavoidable tug at one's core spirit.

     I don't think being a Christian should be comfortable. If we are always comfortable as Christians, we aren't really understanding what it means to be a Christian. We aren't really listening to the revolutionary way Christ calls us to live. Then, to be a pastor is this feeling tenfold, and part of our job as pastors is to be a little uncomfortable all the time and to help our congregations feel a little uncomfortable too.

     Who would choose that path, especially considering it comes with really long hours, often low pay and interminable arguments over the color of the new carpet?

     How do we make our choices? If it is purely intellectual, we are probably doing ourselves a disservice. Sometimes the logical decision is the wrong one. That's the Gospel. It doesn't make any sense but it's just right.

     Sometimes we need to choose the difficult paths, the paths less traveled. We might be surprised what we find there.

     I have a confession to make. I escaped this immersion experience for a while today, I immersed myself in more comfortable surroundings for many hours.  I escaped the poverty and homelessness I have now learned to see more clearly everywhere. When I returned, I put on my headphones and listened to loud music. As I walked through the same streets I have walked through for almost two weeks, I was able to extend my escape a little longer by absorbing myself into the music. I was able to walk past the homeless on the street and avoid feeling much of anything for a few minutes longer. It was like intentionally putting blinders on.  It gave me a little more distance and a lot more comfort.

     That was a choice, too. Do I choose comfort and my blinders or do I choose difficulty and open eyes more often? And if I keep choosing the comfortable path, will I ever be able to find my way back? For that matter, if I keep choosing the difficult path, will there ever be a point of no return on that journey?  Or is it my path to wander between the two, choosing difficulty and uncertainty and the road less traveled when I have the strength and the path of comfort and escape when I need it?

     It is enough to choose the road less traveled only some of the time?

Learn more about what the students were up to on Saturday, January 18th





Today at Old First Presbyterian Church we held another San Francisco Health and Vision Event: 86 individuals received toiletries and socks, 55 individuals received sleeping bags, 43 individuals were connected to prescription eye glasses, 41 women received bras from  Be a Dear and Donate a Brassiere, 40 had their portraits taken by photographer Vince Donovan, 15 people got follow up appointments with social workers at Project Homeless Connect's Every Day Connect, 8 people signed up for Assurance cell phones, 7 individuals visited nurses, others recieved lunch, books and clothing.

 A big thank you to all the partners and volunteers who made today's event a success, including:

  • SF CARES
  • Old First Presbyterian Church
  • Welcome
  • St. Paulus Lutheran Church
  • Project Homeless Connect
  • Be A Dear and Donate a Brassiere
  • Walgreens
  • Vince Donovan
  • Seminarians from Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary 
  • The Castro Lions Club
This project was made possible because of financial support from the Sam Mazza Foundation.  
Our next event will be held at St. Francis Lutheran Church (152 Church Street near Market) on February 22nd from 10am-3pm.
Individuals connected to prescription glasses since our project began: 166

Friday, January 17, 2014

Day Nine - January 14th - Night Ministry - "Uniforms"

Uniforms

We did not do a written reflection journal on Sunday or Monday after our first night of night ministry.  I kinda missed it. It should come as no surprise that I have a need to verbally process. Journaling or talking through it helps.

Last night I wore a clerical collar for the first time.  People looked at me differently. Its hard to define exactly how but somehow they did. At first I thought maybe it was just me, uncomfortable at wearing it for the first time, but I think it was mostly that people looked at me differently and treated me differently.

Today I went back out into the world, this time minus the collar.  The odd, sideways looks were gone.  I was one of the crowd again.  It's amazing how much peoples perception of you changes by wearing a little piece of plastic.

But that's the thing about uniforms, isn't it?  We look at people to figure out who they are by the uniform they are wearing. We all wear uniforms.  There was a folk singer named Peter Alsop who wrote a song about uniforms that came to mind.

     I love my job, I love my boss, I love my paycheck too of course,
     but most of all I love to wear those clothes that keep me warm.
     I fit in with everyone when I'm in my uniform.

     (Chorus)
     Uniforms, Uniforms, wonderful, wonderful clothes,
     When I get up in the morning, from my head down to my toes,
     I've got my uniform, uniform, no decisions to make,
     I just put on my uniform and start my day.

     Levis, or a beach tan, or a polyester knit,
     A jogging suit with stripes, or toe shoes that don't quite fit.
     A cowboy hat, an apron, Phi Beta Kappa key,
     I know all about you and you know me,
     we're in our...

     (Chorus)

     In the military, you gotta wear your proper suit,
     pay attention to insignia, so you know who to salute,
     and in an altercation, well, you know who to shoot,
     If you should die, well, we'll get by, 'cause there's lots of substitutes,
     in the same...

     (Chorus)

     Gray-haired airline pilots, and nurses dressed in white,
     and even fancy couples at the opera at night,
     And sewer workers in their boots, just sloshing to and fro,
     feel safer in a world where everybody knows that those...

We all wear uniforms, even when we are relaxing on our own. What we wear helps define who we are.

What are the uniforms of people around me? Do the poor and homeless have a uniform? Is it dirty hands? Because I have noticed that lately. How much does my uniform assume things about me that may or may not be true?

Every night this week I will wear a collar as I did last night. What do people assume that collar means? For some people, that collar has some very negative connotations. For some it is positive.  But what I need to remember is that those perceptions are not about me as a person. At the same time, I represent the collar, and the behaviors of all before me who have worn it, whether I like it or not. Whether the people I come in contact with see it positively or negatively, I need to own up to all of that, because from here on out, it's my uniform.